As more New York businesses turn to auctions to liquidate assets, misconceptions continue to shape how owners approach the process. From expectations about pricing to assumptions about logistics, many misunderstand how professional auctions function in the state’s highly regulated and competitive market.
Myth 1: Auctions Always Mean Low Returns
One of the most common misconceptions is that auctions automatically result in bargain-basement pricing. In reality, competitive bidding can drive prices higher than what owners might receive through private liquidation or brokered sales.
Auctioneers such as Koster Industries, A.J. Willner Auctions, and Tiger Group use online bidding platforms like BidSpotter, Proxibid, and AuctionZip to attract thousands of verified buyers nationwide. For commercial equipment, vehicles, or branded inventory, this exposure often increases recovery values beyond local resale channels.
Myth 2: Only Large Companies Benefit From Auctions
Some small business owners assume auctions are designed for corporate liquidations or bankruptcy estates. However, in New York, small and mid-size businesses—such as restaurants, salons, and retail shops—regularly use auction services to recoup value from equipment, fixtures, and stock.
Local firms like Best Buy Auctioneers and Michael Amodeo & Co. specialize in smaller lots, often completing clearance projects within days. These firms provide turn-key services including valuation, marketing, removal coordination, and lien compliance, enabling even modest operations to liquidate efficiently.
Myth 3: Auctions Require Too Much Preparation Time
Another misconception is that organizing an auction takes months. In reality, licensed auctioneers operating in New York often move quickly once the inventory list and property access are secured.
For example, restaurant closures or office liquidations can often be marketed and sold within two to three weeks. National firms such as Rabin Worldwide or Heritage Global Partners can expedite timelines by combining on-site cataloging with simultaneous online promotions, ensuring faster turnaround while complying with local ordinances.
Myth 4: Auctions Lack Transparency
Some owners believe auctions favor buyers by concealing true values or imposing hidden fees. In New York, licensed auctioneers are required to provide clear terms, itemized invoices, and documentation of all bids.
Professional firms maintain escrow accounts for proceeds distribution, and many now provide real-time digital reporting to track auction performance. Platforms like Auction Mobility and HiBid allow sellers to monitor bidding as it happens, giving them visibility into the market response.
Myth 5: Local Sales Are Less Effective Than National Auctions
While national exposure helps, not every liquidation benefits from it. For many New York businesses, the highest recovery comes from local bidders who can pick up assets directly and avoid shipping costs.
A local auctioneer’s familiarity with city logistics—such as loading dock access, parking restrictions, and Department of Buildings regulations—can prevent costly delays. Regional firms like Atlas Auctioneers and Caspert Management Co. regularly achieve strong results by targeting area-based buyers who value convenience.
Myth 6: Auctioneers Only Sell Physical Assets
Business owners often overlook that auctions can also include intangible assets such as trademarks, customer lists, and intellectual property. In recent years, several New York technology and retail closures have recovered additional value by including digital assets in their auctions, often facilitated through specialized brokers.
Correcting Misconceptions Leads to Better Outcomes
Understanding the realities of modern auctions helps New York business owners plan strategic exits rather than reactive sales. The state’s auction industry has evolved into a data-driven, technology-enhanced marketplace where timing, transparency, and compliance drive performance.
Whether handled by a Manhattan-based auctioneer or a national firm with New York licensing, auctions remain one of the most efficient methods for converting business assets into capital—when managed with informed expectations.
Looking for an experienced business auctioneer who can produce powerful sales results?
Contact me today, and I will connect you right away with an amazing business auctioneer who I have referred many clients to!
917-913-6093